HollyB

I went and looked up the numbers myself; I found contributions to Obama from Afghanistan OR Iraq when looking up: USMC, USN, NAVY, AIR FORCE, USAF, ARMY, MILITARY, DOD, DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE. but since Afghanistan/Iraq are listed as European theater I can't tell exactly who gave from where I'm sure you can help me on this since you know a majority came from Iraq/Afghanistan.
Also as to your putting their lives on the line statement very few of the donations are listed as coming from APO/FPO are from combat jobs.

You're right a poll isn't a study, just like 160 doesn't mean everyone does it or if an officer does it all enlistedmen do.

Are you seriously going to say none of those donations came from military members serving in Iraq or Afghanistan? Seriously? You did read the article right? I know you quoted me as saying "some voices" and you've already attempted to say I said the whole military.


I didn't say none and the article only has 1 example. My bet is the majority of them didn't. Again, look at the data and prove yourself right instead of bitching at me- you make a statement the burden of proof is on YOU.

Oh puhleaze, I implied nothing of the kind.

You did imply that no troops support McCain.
here:
Thank you for pointing out the fact that not only do military members in Iraq and Afghanistan not support McCain..military members deployed everywhere overwhelmingly support Obama.

When the numbers clearly show that some of them do.

Look Holly this is getting old get over it you were wrong and you think that a majority of 300 people (some of who may be civilian contractors not actual military personnel) could be used to say the majority overseas deployments support Obama.. Of course you conveniently ignore Grid's study of 10,000 military personnel showing overwhelming support for McCain. You're wrong and your blind devotion to all things Obama has caused you to lie to try and get another person to vote for him.

[IMG]

I'll keep that in mind the next time I DON'T SAY THE WHOLE MILITARY.
You're right you just extrapolated the numbers to everyone deployed overseas. Still stupid and dishonest.

"If you believe some voices like active duty military members who are serving in Iraq and Afghanistan and donate 6-1 in favor of Obama, carry more weight than messageboard warriors."
You said Iraq and Afghanistan- the study says all overseas deployments- you can look at the numbers from the FEC yourself and tell me if you're right or stop making statements not made by your sources. As the argument went on you forgot all about your original afghanistan/iraq statement, that's funny.

You also implied that officers would somehow force the men under their command to vote Obama, which is blatantly untrue.

and again " the military donating 6-1 to Obama over McCain and I provided it." The whole military isn't doing that- only about 160 people are- you can try to stretch it to encompass the whole military but we both know that's just stupid.

Your source sucked and didn't make the same claims you did. I may not have have answered the question but I also didn't lie to Piper to prop up my candidate.

So far so good. How about you?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_tVQCIPtcU

Moreover why aren't you leaving messages on Pantherpike or Vpkozel's pages disparaging them?