american Idol 3/28

That's what i said! Taylor sucked, Mandisa's voice sounded like she was winded, Paris, i thought was goood, Elliot! i don't get why they like him so much, i thought his singing sucked tonight, OmG-ACE canNOT sing, please leave! I wasn't impressed with Kelly! I actually thought Bucky did a decent job with the Gary Allen song but i thought Chris' voice would of been more suited for it, though. and Kathrine, i thought she was SEXY and did a good job, i didn't much like the song itself though.

You have 45 minutes left to vote for Kathrine Mcphee...Dial 1-866-436-5708

 

Do real people really make these calls? I thought it was just part of the show and the producers really decide who's staying or leaving?

 

i have a couple of times tonight.


wait.....are you trying to say it's not real?

 

This has to be the worst overall group of Idols ever picked for the show. There are only four or five good singers out of the whole lot and out of that bunch there are only one or two that would even be close to interesting as a musical act. BTW Ace should go he really does suck.

 

From my super secret sources at dialidol.com

DialIdol
Rank Idol Busy Percent Actual Rank
1 Taylor Hicks 72.42 -
2 Katharine McPhee 55.524 -
3 Kellie Pickler 53.815 -
4 Chris Daughtry 48.852 -
5 Bucky Covington 42.996 -
6 Ace Young 40.6 -
7 Elliott Yamin 32.014 -
8 Paris Bennett 29.945 -
9 Mandisa 20.577 -

 

I thought Taylor was horrible last night. Been a fan, but more and more I am seeing he can only do one type of music well.

He will be good in his niche but he probably needs to go soon.

 

My daughter thought that Taylor was bad last night. That's why she spent an hour calling in for him. She got through 16 times.

 

Why in the living loving hell he chose 'Country Roads' will always be a mystery to me. While I'm not a fan of newer country music, I know there was something he could have done that would have shown his talent. Did they have to do Country Music of a certain era? If not, then why not a Merle Haggard or a good Marty Robbins song?
I'm wondering if he wants to leave the show the stupid stuff he's been picking.

 

Me too

 

Yeah, he was my favorite at first but you are right he really is a one trick pony on a show like this. Unless they let him cut loose and jam, getting the harmonica and doing his thing he will be gone before too long. Out of all the folks left Chris Daughtry is the one that I like the best, I thought that what he did last night was a nice change of pace. Also, does anybody outside of FOX News use more double talk than Simon? I generally dig what he says but one week he told Chris that he hasn't compromised and its refreshing to see that, then the next he told him that what he was doing was getting boring, so the next week he rips him for changing. Actually it is kind of funny, he has adult ADD.