add these to the list of future panthers...

How about a few names to choose from? Price and who else?

 

Muhsin's not terribly easy to cut, and he's been somewhat productive when both healthy and he's had a QB who could get more than one ball to a receiver in a game. I'm not against a FA and a pick, but Muhsin's here next year.

 

as a number 2 receiver

 

Key words:

"somewhat"

"when healthy"

I know it's not popular to hate on our only "somewhat productive" WR but you guys have got to agree that the drops, the hammy problems, and his lack of speed do not reflect what Moose has been paid (or what he's about to be paid especially).

I think it was you magnus who convienced me with one of you posts that at best Moose has become a good possession receiver . . . aren't those a dime a dozen?

 

WR's & RB's

WR
----
UFA-upper tier

David Boston
Peerless Price
Ike Hilliard
Eddie Kennison
Kevin Dyson
Oronde Gadsden
Martay Jenkins

UFA-the rest

Reggie Barlow
Chris Carter
Darrin Chiaverini
Demeane Douglas
Bobby Engram
Brian Finneran
Antonio Freeman
Willie Jackson
Patrick Johnson
Kevin Lockett
Terrance Mathis
Herman Moore
Ricky Proehl
Jake Reed
Frank Sanders
Darnay Scott
Bobby Shaw
Brandon Stokley
Derrius Thompson
Michael Westbrook

RFA

Laveranues Coles
Darrell Jackson
Dez White
Karsten Bailey
Avion Black
Chris Cole
JaJuan Dawson
Ron Dixon
Chris Doering
Ron Duggans
Danny Farmer
Larry Foster
Trevor Gaylor
Dante Hall
Scottie Montgomery
Troy Walters

Possible Cuts

Raghib Ismail
Shawn Jefferson
Derrick Alexander
Jermaine Lewis
James Williams

**************
RB's

UFA-upper tier

Olandis Gary
Stacey Mack
Ricky Watters
Leon Johnson
Richie Anderson
Shawn Bryson

UFA-the rest

Mike Cloud
James Johnson
Randy Jordan
Dorsey Levens
Fred McAfee
Brian Mitchell
Lamont Warren
Tyrone Wheatley
Moe Williams

RFA

Troy Hambrick
Jamel White
Ronney Jenkins
Chad Morton
Mike Green
Doug Chapman
KaRon Coleman
Curtis Keaton
Patrick Pass
Aaron Stecker
Michael Wiley

Possible Cuts

Stephen Davis
Emmitt Smith
Antowain Smith

Take your pick boys........

Me, dump Moose, sign Price, Engram, Stokely, and draft a WR at either 1 or 2. Pray we have enough left to sign Davis if he's cut or Mack and a pick in the top 3 rounds.

 

Hey, I'm not a genius like the rest of you but I can look at a FA list and see plenty of guys who would not cost 6 mil a year, who do not have chronic hammys or the dropsies, and can run at LEAST a little faster than Moose. Do you really think that only Price would be an improvement over Moose? Maybe I'm not the only non-genius here after all. )

 

Any of the players above would cost 6mil if they also were entering the 3rd yr of a contract of which was signed after on helluva year..... make sense?

 

Anybody think Moose gets 6 mil anywhere else if he's cut? Nah, didn't think so.

 

My point is that 3years ago he'd have got it from almost any team IMO.

 

no, not really. You don't buy a guy and say "well this is his role on the team."
If that were possible, we certainly wouldn't have what we have.

And no, I seriously don't see us actually going out and getting anyone better than him.