Which QB would you rather have?

I'm curious as to what the group thinks.

 

Luck has everything. That said fuck him for staying in another year

 

RGIII is certainly making me reconsider with his recent play, but I'll still go with Luck if for nothing else than Luck's chances of survival over the long hall. Athletically, Luck compares most favorably to Aaron Rogers IMO given his size, speed, and ability to throw darts on the run outside the pocket. But its between the ears where he really sets himself apart, and from that perspective, he reminds me of Steve Young.

 

Bob is playing really well right now but I agree about the longevity of Luck.

 

I wish we had Luck for sure. That said, I hope the fucking bastard gets like ten concussions and has to retire before he hits his prime, gets herpes, anything else bad.

 

Like them both but RGIII can do both run and throw!

 

RG3 is benefiting from the offense a lot like Cam did last season.

 

Bingo.

Hopefully we can get some coaching for Cam next year.

My Pop pointed out to me over Thanksgiving that in the lockout year when Cam spent all that time with Weinke at IMG he played better than having a full offseason with his coaches in year 2. Never thought of it that way but that's a hell of an indictment if you ask me.

Guess I'd vote for Luck between these two....but its close.

 

Cam isn't struggling due to a lack of coaching. He's struggling because opposing defenses didn't have much time last season to coach the things that limit him. RG3 doesn't have the same limitations that Newton does in terms of his inability to read defenses and poor footwork, but NFL teams will still adjust to the things Washington has been doing.

 

Clearly I would take either one over Cam. I think RG3 is a superstar in the making if he can stay healthy. I understand and agree with the criticism that his slight frame and talent running the ball are not a good combination.

I'll be extremely intrigued to see how both do next year after NFL teams adjust to what they do.